But I Can Prove I’m Innocent’: Why English Courts Won’t Decide Guilt in Extradition Proceedings
If you have been arrested in England on an extradition warrant, your first instinct might be to explain why you are innocent. You may have documents, witnesses or other accounts which you believe clearly demonstrate why the allegations made against you are false.
It is understandable that you would want to present this evidence to the court as soon as possible. However, one of the important things to understand about extradition proceedings is that English courts are not concerned with deciding whether you are guilty or innocent of the underlying offence.
This can be difficult to accept, particularly when you believe you have compelling evidence to support your case. Understanding early on what the English courts can and cannot consider when deciding whether to extradite you, is essential to ensuring that your defence against extradition is effective and focused.
Why won’t the English Courts consider my evidence of innocence?
While extradition is a specialist area of criminal law; extradition proceedings are very different to usual criminal proceedings.
When another country requests your extradition, the role of the English court is not to decide on your guilt or innocence. Extradition proceedings involve two countries with two different legal systems. A judge sitting in an English court does not have the authority or the required knowledge and expertise to decide on your guilt in a different legal system.
Instead, the court must decide whether the legal requirements for extradition have been met and whether there are grounds under the Extradition Act to prevent your extradition.
This means that even if you have evidence which you believe proves your innocence, the English court will not examine that evidence to determine whether you committed the offence.
Similarly, if you have already been convicted in the country that seeks your extradition, the English court cannot act as an appeal court and does not have the power to overturn that conviction.
This does not mean your evidence is irrelevant. It means it should be presented to a court in the country where you allegedly committed the offence.
What should I do with my evidence?
If you have evidence which challenges the allegations made against you, it is important that it is properly considered.
In many cases, we recommend that clients instruct a criminal defence lawyer in the country requesting extradition, who can work alongside your extradition solicitors in England. A foreign lawyer can evaluate your evidence and advise you on the right steps to take in that country.
A foreign lawyer may be able to challenge the allegations, make an application to discontinue the proceedings, or lodge an appeal against conviction which could result in the extradition warrant being withdrawn and you being discharged from the extradition proceedings. However, this will depend on the law and procedures of the requesting country, and each case must be decided on its own merits.
Instructing a foreign lawyer can help you in your extradition proceedings in other ways as well. They might be able to obtain certain evidence that supports the arguments we intend to raise, such as your potential right to a re-trial.
Crucially, while those steps are being taken abroad, the extradition proceedings in England will continue. It is therefore important not to neglect your defence in England.
Most common arguments used against extradition
Rather than attempting to prove your innocence, your extradition solicitor will focus on the legal arguments that the English courts are permitted to consider.
Depending on your circumstances, these may include the following:
1. Human Rights
Under the Extradition Act 2003, extradition must be compatible with your rights under the European Convention on Human Rights.
Some of the most relevant rights in extradition cases include:
- Article 8- Right to Private and Family Life
Extradition can have a devastating impact on family life, particularly where you have lived in the UK for many years, have a partner and children here, or significant caring responsibilities.The court should consider whether extradition would be a disproportionate interference with your right to a private and family life.However, family separation or an established life in the UK will not necessarily prevent your extradition. The court must balance the impact on you and your family against the public interest in extradition. Article 3- Prohibition of Torture and Inhuman and Degrading Treatment
If there are substantial grounds for believing that you would face a real risk of torture or inhuman or degrading treatment in the requesting country, this may provide grounds to resist extradition.
This usually relates to concerns about prison conditions or treatment in detention. Your extradition solicitors will instruct experts in this field to support any arguments regarding a risk of breach of your Article 3 rights.
Article 6- Right to a fair trial
In some cases, there may be serious concerns about whether you have received or would receive a fair trial in the requesting country. It is important to keep in mind that this is a high threshold, and the fact that some legal systems are different to others, does not automatically mean that there has been a breach fair trial rights.
2. Other Legal Grounds Under the Extradition Act
Depending on the type of extradition request and the exact requesting state, there may also be specific statutory grounds to challenge extradition.
This can include:
- Section 10 – Extradition Offence: The court must consider whether the conduct would amount to a criminal offence in England.
- Section 14 – Passage of Time: In certain circumstances, extradition may be barred where the passage of time in bringing proceedings against you would make extradition unjust or oppressive.
- Section 20 – Conviction in Absence: Where a person has been convicted without being present at trial, the court may need to consider whether they deliberately absented themselves and, if not, whether they would be entitled to a re-trial.
The available grounds depend on the requesting country, whether you are accused or convicted, and on your individual circumstances.
The importance of having the right strategy
Facing extradition can be frightening, especially when you feel that nobody is willing to listen to your side of the story.
The fact that your extradition solicitor is not concentrating on proving your innocence does not mean that your evidence is being ignored. It means that your legal team must focus on the arguments which the English courts actually have the power to consider.
In many cases, the most effective approach is to work on two fronts: challenging the underlying allegations or convictions through a lawyer in the requesting country, while preparing a defence against extradition in England.
The key is understanding which arguments belong in which court.
If you have concerns about extradition to any foreign state, please get in touch with our Extradition Solicitors to arrange a consultation with one of our experts now. Call us now on 0330 822 3451 or request a callback.
Out of office hours, call our 24/7 Emergency Number: 0808 274 8226